Why Coaches Should Focus on Meritocracy
A Coaching Philosophy Centered on Merit

Coaching goes far beyond teaching the technical aspects of a sport. It involves creating an environment where every athlete feels valued, motivated, and accountable. One of the most effective ways to build this culture is through meritocracy—a system that rewards performance and effort over other factors such as favoritism, seniority, or personal connections.

By fostering a meritocratic environment, coaches can ensure fairness, build trust, and unlock their team's full potential. Here’s why focusing on meritocracy is essential for creating winning teams:

1. Fairness and Transparency

Meritocracy ensures that athletes know their opportunities and playing time are based solely on their performance and effort. This transparency fosters a sense of justice, which is critical for team cohesion. When athletes believe that they are judged fairly, they are more likely to commit themselves fully to the team's success.

Coach Tip: To maintain fairness and transparency, establish clear criteria for performance and communicate them consistently. A rubric detailing the skills and behaviors needed to earn playing time can help athletes understand the expectations. Regularly assessing and communicating with athletes based on this rubric will eliminate ambiguity and foster trust.

2. Motivation and Accountability

In a meritocratic system, athletes understand that their advancement is directly tied to their performance. This drives self-motivation, as players know their efforts will lead to increased opportunities. They also become more accountable, realizing that success is within their control.

Coach Tip: Consistently reward hard work and progress, even if it doesn’t lead to immediate results. When athletes and their families see that merit is the primary determinant of success, they will be more willing to trust the process. Actions speak louder than words—make sure you back up your philosophy with consistent decisions.

3. Team Unity and Collaboration

Meritocracy helps build trust among teammates because everyone knows their place on the team is earned. This fosters mutual respect and enhances teamwork. When players trust that everyone on the field has earned their spot, it strengthens the collective effort.

Coach Tip: When athletes question their playing time or role on the team, always refer back to your performance rubric. Consistency is key. Keep the message clear—if players want more opportunities, they must level up their performance to match the standards you’ve set.

4. Maximizing Talent Potential

A merit-based system ensures that the most skilled and hardworking athletes take on pivotal roles, maximizing the team's potential. By focusing on merit, you can ensure that each player contributes to the team's overall success, allowing their strengths to shine and elevating the entire group.

Coach Tip: Encourage leadership roles for your top performers, but also give opportunities for emerging players to take ownership during games. This helps your star players grow as leaders while providing a roadmap for others to follow.

5. Player Development

A meritocratic approach doesn't just reward current success; it also fosters growth and development for all players. By emphasizing improvement and rewarding effort, even those who start at a lower skill level can see a path forward. This makes the team stronger in the long run, as players continuously strive to meet higher standards.

Coach Tip: Regularly communicate with players about what specific skills or behaviors they need to improve to earn more playing time. Giving concrete, actionable feedback not only helps them grow but also shows that you are invested in their development.

6. Building a Culture of Trust

When athletes see that coaches are consistent in applying meritocratic principles, it builds trust. They know that effort, discipline, and hard work will be rewarded, and this trust encourages them to keep pushing even when they face setbacks. Meritocracy creates a culture where athletes feel secure in the knowledge that their development is within their control.

Coach Tip: Create team-building exercises that reinforce the idea of trust and accountability. When your team trusts the process and each other, they will be more cohesive, resilient, and motivated to achieve collective goals.

Conclusion

Meritocracy in sports is about more than just selecting the best players—it’s about creating an environment where fairness, accountability, and development are the cornerstones of the team culture. By focusing on merit, coaches can maximize their team’s potential, foster unity, and build trust. This approach not only leads to better performance on the field but also helps athletes grow as individuals, instilling lifelong values of discipline, effort, and accountability.

Coaches who consistently emphasize meritocracy will build stronger teams, develop better players, and create an environment where everyone knows that success is earned through hard work and dedication.

Coach Luc Tremblay is the Founder and Head Coach of Volleyball Winnipeg. Luc has been coaching volleyball for 30+ years with athletes of all age classes and all abilities. He has developed most of the training techniques used by VISION coaches and is responsible for the coach development program at Volleyball Winnipeg. For more details on our Coach Resources, click here. 
Share with a Friend